Difficulty & Success Reference
The Difficulty Ladder
| Diff | Label | When to Use |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | Easy | Perfect conditions, no pressure |
| 4 | Routine | Muscle memory carries you through |
| 5 | Straightforward | Clear procedure, requires focus |
| 6 | Standard | Default for everything that matters |
| 7 | Challenging | Bad lighting, active resistance |
| 8 | Difficult | Environment works against you |
| 9 | Extremely Difficult | Foolhardy — needs the Force or luck |
| 10 | Nearly Impossible | Epic songs are written about this |
Interactive Calculator
| Net Suc. \ Diff | 3Easy | 4Routine | 5Straightforward | 6Standard | 7Challenging | 8Difficult | 9Extremely Difficult | 10Nearly Impossible |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1+ | 98.72% | 97.22% | 94.60% | 90.13% | 82.91% | 71.80% | 55.39% | 32.09% |
| 2+ | 96.14% | 92.65% | 86.69% | 77.56% | 64.59% | 47.68% | 28.01% | 9.30% |
| 3+ | 91.11% | 83.43% | 72.61% | 58.36% | 41.55% | 24.31% | 9.93% | 1.70% |
| 4+ | 79.75% | 67.90% | 52.60% | 36.00% | 20.61% | 8.95% | 2.38% | 0.20% |
| 5+ | 64.55% | 47.06% | 30.56% | 16.75% | 7.26% | 2.22% | 0.37% | 0.01% |
Rows show the chance of rolling at least N net successes with 7 dice. Each 1 cancels one success. Values update immediately when inputs change.
Redefining Success
The game wants difficulty and number of successes needed to work together. A single knob is not enough.
With the default "1 net success = marginal success" and difficulty 10, a starting specialist (5 dice) succeeds 28% of the time. That does not feel "nearly impossible." But if you raise the bar — "a true success needs 3 net successes" — that same roll drops to 0.69%. That feels impossible.
The problem is that requiring 3+ successes means a 2-die pool can never succeed at all. So you calibrate both knobs together:
| Tone | Typical Diff | Success Threshold | Feel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cinematic heroes | 4–6 | 1 net success | PCs mostly succeed; drama comes from the story |
| Balanced | 6–7 | 1–2 net successes | Skill matters; PCs sweat the hard rolls |
| Brutal / Unforgiving | 7–10 | 3+ net successes | Only specialists can achieve true success; most tasks are desperate gambles |
Knob 1: Difficulty
Difficulty controls how many dice even become successes. Raise it (7–10) when the environment, equipment, or opposition actively works against the character — shooting in the dark, hacking an Imperial core, negotiating with a Moff. Lower it (3–5) when conditions favor them — point-blank shot, well-understood system, friendly audience.
Knob 2: Success Threshold
The threshold says how many net successes you need to call it a win. A low threshold (1) rewards luck — anyone can get lucky once. A high threshold (3+) rewards sustained skill — small pools cannot reliably reach it.
Four Combinations
High difficulty + low threshold — The task itself is punishing, but you only need to get lucky once. A single blaster bolt hitting a thermal exhaust port at extreme range: difficulty 9, 1 net success needed. Hard to roll, but one lucky die is enough.
Low difficulty + high threshold — The basics are easy, but you need flawless execution under scrutiny. A protocol droid serving drinks at an Imperial gala without a single mistake: difficulty 4, 3 net successes needed. Each individual roll is easy, but the total demand is high — one botch and you've spilled on an Admiral.
High difficulty + high threshold — You need both luck and skill. Convincing a Jedi Master you're worthy of training while he's actively probing your mind: difficulty 9, 4 net successes needed. Only the best combination of pool size and luck will do.
Low difficulty + low threshold — Routine task. Walking across a room: difficulty 3, 1 net success.
Reference Table
| Tone | Diff | Threshold | Example situation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cinematic | 4–6 | 1 | Convincing a guard with a good story (diff 5, threshold 1) — even a smooth talker with 3 dice succeeds 70% of the time |
| Cinematic, harder task | 7–8 | 1 | Hacking a military terminal (diff 7, threshold 1) — hard roll but one success is enough; a specialist has 54% |
| Balanced | 5–6 | 2 | Impressing a Hutt with a clever negotiation (diff 5, threshold 2) — a specialist (7 dice) has 78%, an amateur (4 dice) has 45% |
| Balanced, harder task | 7–8 | 2 | Repairing a hyperdrive under fire (diff 7, threshold 2) — a specialist has 32%, a 10-die expert has 57% |
| Brutal | 5–6 | 3 | Performing a surgical strike on a vital console (diff 6, threshold 3) — a specialist (7 dice) has 38%, an amateur (4 dice) has 11% |
| Brutal, impossible task | 8–10 | 3+ | Convincing a Sith Lord to spare you (diff 9, threshold 4) — a 10-die specialist has 3%, and even 15 dice only reach 17% |
Use the calculator above to find the sweet spot for your table.
Cross-References
- Building Encounters — NPC tiers, encounter balance
- Dice Pools — How dice pools work, the Rule of One
- Combat Flow — Attack resolution, cover modifiers
- Combat Scales — Scale-based difficulty modifiers
- Health, Damage & Healing — Healing difficulty table